- Monday Eve - February 3, 2020

? Explanation of report features  
Download hands in PDF or PBN format (Right click and choose “Save Link As...” in Firefox or “Save Target As...” in IE)
Jump directly to board 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20
Field strength:  Mean: 239 MP  Geomean: 61 MP
(based on 20 players)
★ ★ ★  Masterpoint Winners  ★ ★ ★
Partnership Pct Rank MP
Beth Murphy - Sherri Lampert 70.00 1st A 0.40
Ken Goldberg - Mark Levin 58.75 2nd A 0.28
Harry Tischler - James Masterson 58.13 1st A 0.40
Andy Carr - Jane O'Connor 51.25 2nd A 0.28
Rosemary Porter - Susan Bergin Wilson 41.88 1st C 0.12
EVENT>Zero To 750              |SESSION>Monday Eve   |SECTION> A N-S
------------------------,------ ------------,-------- --------------------------
DATE>February 3, 2020   |CLUB NO.>227439    | 02/03/2020 21:32
---------------------,-- ------------------- -------------,---------------------
DIR> John Nothdurft  |RATING>Club Masterpoint (80%, 80%, 60% Open)|MOVEMENT>MITCHELL
------------,-------- ,-------------------------,--------- ---------------------
AVE>   40.0 |TOP>   4 |MP LIMITS>750/300/50     |CLUB>Yorktown Bridge Club
------------ --------- ------------------------- -------------------------------
PAIRS IN STRAT A=5/B=3/C=3                       ,---,-------------------------,------,---------,
-------------------------------------------------|   |           Section       |      |Section  |
No Name                   Name                   |Flt|Rnk-A|Rnk-B|Rnk-C| Score | Pct  |Awards   |
------------------------------------------------- --- ----- ----- ----- ------- ------ ---------
 1 Max Lieberman          Edie McAlpin             A    NE    .     .     47.00  58.75
 2 James Masterson        Harry Tischler           A    1     .     .     46.50  58.13  0.40(A)
 3 Michael Sheketoff      Meg Sheketoff            C    .     .     .     33.50  41.88
 4 Andy Carr              Jane O'Connor            C    2     1     1     41.00  51.25  0.28(A)
 5 Shelley Schwartz       Roy Schwartz             C    .     .     .     32.00  40.00
                                          Totals                         200.00

EVENT>Zero To 750              |SESSION>Monday Eve   |SECTION> A E-W
------------------------,------ ------------,-------- --------------------------
AVE>   40.0 |TOP>   4 |MP LIMITS>750/300/50     |CLUB>Yorktown Bridge Club
------------ --------- ------------------------- -------------------------------
PAIRS IN STRAT A=5/B=5/C=2                       ,---,-------------------------,------,---------,
-------------------------------------------------|   |           Section       |      |Section  |
No Name                   Name                   |Flt|Rnk-A|Rnk-B|Rnk-C| Score | Pct  |Awards   |
------------------------------------------------- --- ----- ----- ----- ------- ------ ---------
 1 Stephanie Fine         Richard Greenberg        B    .     .     .     31.50  39.38
 2 Sherri Lampert         Beth Murphy              B    1     1     .     56.00  70.00  0.40(A)
 3 Mark Levin             Ken Goldberg             B    2     2     .     47.00  58.75  0.28(A)
 4 Rosemary Porter        Susan Bergin Wilson      C    .     .     1     33.50  41.88  0.12(C)
 5 John Nothdurft         Margy Dooley             C    .     .     .     32.00  40.00
                                          Totals                         200.00

Hands and Results
1 ♠654
83
632
♣AJ865
Dlr: North
Vul: None
♠T8732
AQT4
KJT4
♣-
♠AK
K9765
Q75
♣QT9
♠QJ9
J2
A98
♣K7432
5
1014
11
Double Dummy Makes
NS:  ♣6 ♦1 ♥1 ♠2 NT3
EW: 1♣ 5 6 4♠ 2NT
LoTT: 18 - 19 = -1
Par: -980 6-EW
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract
        450    3.00   1.00  4♠ E +1   A3-Sheketoff-Sheketoff vs A5-Nothdurft-Dooley
        450    3.00   1.00  4 E +1   A4-Carr-O'Connor vs A2-Lampert-Murphy
        450    3.00   1.00  4 E +1   A5-Schwartz-Schwartz vs A4-Porter-Bergin Wilson
        480    0.50   3.50  4 E +2   A1-Lieberman-McAlpin vs A1-Fine-Greenberg
        480    0.50   3.50  4 E +2   A2-Masterson-Tischler vs A3-Levin-Goldberg
2 ♠T
AT943
J763
♣T92
Dlr: East
Vul: N-S
♠AK76
KQJ
KT54
♣76
♠9843
65
A82
♣KQ53
♠QJ52
872
Q9
♣AJ84
5
169
10
Double Dummy Makes
NS: 1  ♣5 ♦5 ♠4 NT5
EW: 1♣ 2 3♠ 2NT  ♥6
LoTT: 16 - 16 = 0
Par: -140 3♠-EW
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract
  150          4.00   0.00  4♠ W -3   A2-Masterson-Tischler vs A3-Levin-Goldberg
  100          2.50   1.50  4♠ W -2   A3-Sheketoff-Sheketoff vs A5-Nothdurft-Dooley
  100          2.50   1.50  4♠ E -2   A1-Lieberman-McAlpin vs A1-Fine-Greenberg
   50          1.00   3.00  4♠ W -1   A4-Carr-O'Connor vs A2-Lampert-Murphy
        120    0.00   4.00  2N W      A5-Schwartz-Schwartz vs A4-Porter-Bergin Wilson
3 ♠98762
52
K73
♣KT9
Dlr: South
Vul: E-W
♠3
QJ9764
94
♣Q653
♠AT
AKT3
QJT82
♣J2
♠KQJ54
8
A65
♣A874
6
515
14
Double Dummy Makes
NS: 2♣ 3♠  ♦5 ♥4 NT6
EW: 2 3 1NT  ♣5 ♠3
LoTT: 18 - 20 = -2
Par: +140 3♠-NS
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract
  420          3.00   1.00  4♠ S      A1-Lieberman-McAlpin vs A1-Fine-Greenberg
  420          3.00   1.00  4♠ S      A2-Masterson-Tischler vs A3-Levin-Goldberg
  420          3.00   1.00  4♠ S      A4-Carr-O'Connor vs A2-Lampert-Murphy
  200          1.00   3.00  5 W -2   A5-Schwartz-Schwartz vs A4-Porter-Bergin Wilson
         50    0.00   4.00  4♠ S -1   A3-Sheketoff-Sheketoff vs A5-Nothdurft-Dooley
4 ♠984
8732
Q85
♣AQ4
Dlr: West
Vul: Both
♠KT53
AJ
JT72
♣532
♠QJ76
T654
6
♣J876
♠A2
KQ9
AK943
♣KT9
8
94
19
Double Dummy Makes
NS: 2♣ 3 3 1♠ 2NT
EW:  ♣5 ♦4 ♥4 ♠6 NT5
LoTT: 15 - 16 = -1
Par: +140 3-NS
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract
  600          3.00   1.00  3N S      A1-Lieberman-McAlpin vs A1-Fine-Greenberg
  600          3.00   1.00  3N S      A3-Sheketoff-Sheketoff vs A5-Nothdurft-Dooley
  600          3.00   1.00  3N S      A5-Schwartz-Schwartz vs A4-Porter-Bergin Wilson
  110          1.00   3.00  1 S +2   A2-Masterson-Tischler vs A3-Levin-Goldberg
        500    0.00   4.00  5* S -2  A4-Carr-O'Connor vs A2-Lampert-Murphy
5 ♠92
JT
A973
♣JT932
Dlr: North
Vul: N-S
♠AQJ
965
QJT5
♣A75
♠K8
KQ8732
64
♣K84
♠T76543
A4
K82
♣Q6
6
1411
9
Double Dummy Makes
NS:  ♣6 ♦4/5 ♥3 ♠6 NT3
EW: 1♣ 1 4 4NT  ♠6
LoTT: 16 - 17 = -1
Par: -430 4NT-EW
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract
        170    3.00   1.00  3 E +1   A1-Lieberman-McAlpin vs A5-Nothdurft-Dooley
        170    3.00   1.00  2 E +2   A3-Sheketoff-Sheketoff vs A4-Porter-Bergin Wilson
        170    3.00   1.00  2 E +2   A4-Carr-O'Connor vs A1-Fine-Greenberg
        430    1.00   3.00  3N W +1   A5-Schwartz-Schwartz vs A3-Levin-Goldberg
        450    0.00   4.00  4 E +1   A2-Masterson-Tischler vs A2-Lampert-Murphy
6 ♠-
J52
AQT42
♣AKQ93
Dlr: East
Vul: E-W
♠AJ65
T97
K7
♣T642
♠Q8742
Q6
98653
♣7
♠KT93
AK843
J
♣J85
16
84
12
Double Dummy Makes
NS: 7♣ 5 6 1♠ 5/6NT
EW:  ♣0 ♦2 ♥0 ♠6 NT0
LoTT: 19 - 17 = +2
Par: +1440 7♣-NS
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract
  980          4.00   0.00  6 S      A1-Lieberman-McAlpin vs A5-Nothdurft-Dooley
  450          2.50   1.50  4 S +1   A2-Masterson-Tischler vs A2-Lampert-Murphy
  450          2.50   1.50  4 S +1   A4-Carr-O'Connor vs A1-Fine-Greenberg
  430          1.00   3.00  4N S      A5-Schwartz-Schwartz vs A3-Levin-Goldberg
  420          0.00   4.00  4 S      A3-Sheketoff-Sheketoff vs A4-Porter-Bergin Wilson
7 ♠T7
732
AQT982
♣J7
Dlr: South
Vul: Both
♠A8654
T6
63
♣Q543
♠QJ9
9854
J7
♣KT98
♠K32
AKQJ
K54
♣A62
7
67
20
Double Dummy Makes
NS: 5 5 4/5NT  ♣6/5 ♠5
EW: 1♣ 1♠  ♦2 ♥2 NT2
LoTT: 18 - 17 = +1
Par: +660 5NT-N
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract
  690          3.50   0.50  3N S +3   A3-Sheketoff-Sheketoff vs A4-Porter-Bergin Wilson
  690          3.50   0.50  3N S +3   A4-Carr-O'Connor vs A1-Fine-Greenberg
  660          2.00   2.00  3N S +2   A1-Lieberman-McAlpin vs A5-Nothdurft-Dooley
  650          1.00   3.00  4 S +1   A2-Masterson-Tischler vs A2-Lampert-Murphy
  630          0.00   4.00  3N S +1   A5-Schwartz-Schwartz vs A3-Levin-Goldberg
8 ♠JT32
J65
AQ86
♣T4
Dlr: West
Vul: None
♠A
7
KJ73
♣AKQ9872
♠KQ975
AQ3
T42
♣J3
♠864
KT9842
95
♣65
8
1712
3
Double Dummy Makes
NS: 1  ♣1 ♦3 ♠2 NT2
EW: 4/5♣ 4 3♠ 5NT  ♥6
LoTT: 18 - 18 = 0
Par: -460 5NT-EW
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract
        400    4.00   0.00  5♣ W      A4-Carr-O'Connor vs A1-Fine-Greenberg
        440    3.00   1.00  5♣ W +2   A3-Sheketoff-Sheketoff vs A4-Porter-Bergin Wilson
        490    1.50   2.50  3N W +3   A5-Schwartz-Schwartz vs A3-Levin-Goldberg
        490    1.50   2.50  3N E +3   A1-Lieberman-McAlpin vs A5-Nothdurft-Dooley
        990    0.00   4.00  6N E      A2-Masterson-Tischler vs A2-Lampert-Murphy
9 ♠KJ93
74
Q83
♣T943
Dlr: North
Vul: E-W
♠AQT74
J62
94
♣AJ8
♠8
A985
AJ752
♣KQ7
♠652
KQT3
KT6
♣652
6
1214
8
Double Dummy Makes
NS:  ♣5 ♦4 ♥3 ♠5 NT5
EW: 2♣ 2 3 2♠ 1NT
LoTT: 14 - 14 = 0
Par: -140 3-EW
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract
  300          3.50   0.50  3N W -3   A2-Masterson-Tischler vs A1-Fine-Greenberg
  300          3.50   0.50  3N E -3   A3-Sheketoff-Sheketoff vs A3-Levin-Goldberg
  200          2.00   2.00  3N E -2   A5-Schwartz-Schwartz vs A2-Lampert-Murphy
  100          1.00   3.00  3♣ E -1   A1-Lieberman-McAlpin vs A4-Porter-Bergin Wilson
        600    0.00   4.00  3N E      A4-Carr-O'Connor vs A5-Nothdurft-Dooley
10 ♠J876
AQT6
AQT
♣65
Dlr: East
Vul: Both
♠53
J94
J864
♣T732
♠KT942
K87
K9
♣AQ4
♠AQ
532
7532
♣KJ98
13
215
10
Double Dummy Makes
NS: 2♣ 2 3 2♠ 3NT
EW:  ♣4 ♦4 ♥4 ♠5 NT4
LoTT: 14 - 14 = 0
Par: +600 3NT-NS
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract
  100          4.00   0.00  2♠ E -1   A4-Carr-O'Connor vs A5-Nothdurft-Dooley
         80    3.00   1.00  1♠ E      A2-Masterson-Tischler vs A1-Fine-Greenberg
        100    2.00   2.00  3N N -1   A3-Sheketoff-Sheketoff vs A3-Levin-Goldberg
        200    0.50   3.50  2N* N -1  A5-Schwartz-Schwartz vs A2-Lampert-Murphy
        200    0.50   3.50  3♣ S -2   A1-Lieberman-McAlpin vs A4-Porter-Bergin Wilson
11 ♠AT94
7
QJ876
♣T96
Dlr: South
Vul: None
♠Q75
J54
92
♣Q7542
♠-
AKT98
A543
♣KJ83
♠KJ8632
Q632
KT
♣A
7
515
13
Double Dummy Makes
NS: 2 5♠ 1NT  ♣3 ♥4
EW: 3♣ 3  ♦5/4 ♠2 NT3
LoTT: 20 - 19 = +1
Par: +450 5♠-NS
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract
  630          4.00   0.00  3♠* S +1  A4-Carr-O'Connor vs A5-Nothdurft-Dooley
  450          2.00   2.00  4♠ S +1   A1-Lieberman-McAlpin vs A4-Porter-Bergin Wilson
  450          2.00   2.00  4♠ S +1   A2-Masterson-Tischler vs A1-Fine-Greenberg
  450          2.00   2.00  4♠ S +1   A5-Schwartz-Schwartz vs A2-Lampert-Murphy
  420          0.00   4.00  4♠ S      A3-Sheketoff-Sheketoff vs A3-Levin-Goldberg
12 ♠753
J862
95
♣J864
Dlr: West
Vul: N-S
♠JT98
AQ9
J43
♣A92
♠A2
KT53
AK87
♣Q75
♠KQ64
74
QT62
♣KT3
2
1216
10
Double Dummy Makes
NS:  ♣4 ♦3 ♥3 ♠3 NT3
EW: 3/2♣ 4 4 4♠ 4NT
LoTT: 14 - 14 = 0
Par: -430 4NT-EW
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract
   50          4.00   0.00  4 E -1   A1-Lieberman-McAlpin vs A4-Porter-Bergin Wilson
        140    3.00   1.00  3 E      A2-Masterson-Tischler vs A1-Fine-Greenberg
        400    1.50   2.50  3N W      A3-Sheketoff-Sheketoff vs A3-Levin-Goldberg
        400    1.50   2.50  3N E      A4-Carr-O'Connor vs A5-Nothdurft-Dooley
        430    0.00   4.00  3N E +1   A5-Schwartz-Schwartz vs A2-Lampert-Murphy
13 ♠KJ
AKQ9732
53
♣QJ
Dlr: North
Vul: Both
♠8763
8
KQ9
♣AT964
♠T95
JT
AJT8742
♣K
♠AQ42
654
6
♣87532
16
99
6
Double Dummy Makes
NS: 4  ♣6 ♦1 ♠6 NT2
EW: 3 1♠  ♣6 ♥2 NT3
LoTT: 19 - 20 = -1
Par: +500 5*-EW-2
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract
  680          4.00   0.00  4 N +2   A1-Lieberman-McAlpin vs A3-Levin-Goldberg
  650          2.50   1.50  4 N +1   A4-Carr-O'Connor vs A4-Porter-Bergin Wilson
  650          2.50   1.50  4 N +1   A5-Schwartz-Schwartz vs A1-Fine-Greenberg
  100          1.00   3.00  4 E -1   A3-Sheketoff-Sheketoff vs A2-Lampert-Murphy
        170    0.00   4.00  4 E +2   A2-Masterson-Tischler vs A5-Nothdurft-Dooley
14 ♠T73
AT986
A82
♣87
Dlr: East
Vul: None
♠642
Q54
KJ64
♣T53
♠Q95
K2
Q975
♣J942
♠AKJ8
J73
T3
♣AKQ6
8
68
18
Double Dummy Makes
NS: 4♣ 2 5 5♠ 3NT
EW:  ♣3 ♦5 ♥1 ♠1 NT1
LoTT: 16 - 16 = 0
Par: +450 5♠-NS/5-NS
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract
  480          4.00   0.00  4♠ S +2   A1-Lieberman-McAlpin vs A3-Levin-Goldberg
  430          3.00   1.00  3N S +1   A2-Masterson-Tischler vs A5-Nothdurft-Dooley
  400          2.00   2.00  3N N      A5-Schwartz-Schwartz vs A1-Fine-Greenberg
  200          1.00   3.00  1♠ S +4   A4-Carr-O'Connor vs A4-Porter-Bergin Wilson
  150          0.00   4.00  2N N +1   A3-Sheketoff-Sheketoff vs A2-Lampert-Murphy
15 ♠KQ74
KQ98
J
♣Q753
Dlr: South
Vul: N-S
♠J6
762
KT98
♣T842
♠T83
T53
AQ732
♣J6
♠A952
AJ4
654
♣AK9
13
47
16
Double Dummy Makes
NS: 5♣ 1 6 6♠ 2NT
EW:  ♣2 ♦6 ♥1 ♠1 NT2
LoTT: 18 - 17 = +1
Par: +1430 6♠-NS/6-NS
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract
  680          3.00   1.00  4♠ S +2   A1-Lieberman-McAlpin vs A3-Levin-Goldberg
  680          3.00   1.00  4♠ S +2   A2-Masterson-Tischler vs A5-Nothdurft-Dooley
  680          3.00   1.00  4♠ S +2   A4-Carr-O'Connor vs A4-Porter-Bergin Wilson
  650          1.00   3.00  4♠ S +1   A5-Schwartz-Schwartz vs A1-Fine-Greenberg
  600          0.00   4.00  3N S      A3-Sheketoff-Sheketoff vs A2-Lampert-Murphy
16 ♠T7653
A9753
5
♣62
Dlr: West
Vul: E-W
♠AK
T864
K874
♣A84
♠Q9842
K2
A3
♣KQT7
♠J
QJ
QJT962
♣J953
4
1414
8
Double Dummy Makes
NS:  ♣3 ♦5 ♥4 ♠2 NT2
EW: 4♣ 2 3 5♠ 5NT
LoTT: 16 - 14 = +2
Par: -660 5NT-EW
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract
        130    4.00   0.00  4♣ E      A2-Masterson-Tischler vs A5-Nothdurft-Dooley
        250    3.00   1.00  5 N -5   A4-Carr-O'Connor vs A4-Porter-Bergin Wilson
        630    2.00   2.00  3N W +1   A5-Schwartz-Schwartz vs A1-Fine-Greenberg
        660    1.00   3.00  3N W +2   A1-Lieberman-McAlpin vs A3-Levin-Goldberg
        790    0.00   4.00  4♠* E     A3-Sheketoff-Sheketoff vs A2-Lampert-Murphy
17 ♠864
J9862
Q94
♣K9
Dlr: North
Vul: None
♠J972
KQ4
A7
♣QJ83
♠KQ53
A3
KJ652
♣T6
♠AT
T75
T83
♣A7542
6
1313
8
Double Dummy Makes
NS:  ♣4 ♦2 ♥5 ♠2 NT3
EW: 3♣ 3 2 4♠ 4NT
LoTT: 15 - 16 = -1
Par: -430 4NT-EW
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract
  100          4.00   0.00  4♠ W -2   A2-Masterson-Tischler vs A4-Porter-Bergin Wilson
        170    3.00   1.00  2♠ W +2   A5-Schwartz-Schwartz vs A5-Nothdurft-Dooley
        420    1.50   2.50  4♠ W      A1-Lieberman-McAlpin vs A2-Lampert-Murphy
        420    1.50   2.50  4♠ W      A4-Carr-O'Connor vs A3-Levin-Goldberg
        450    0.00   4.00  4♠ W +1   A3-Sheketoff-Sheketoff vs A1-Fine-Greenberg
18 ♠74
AJ975
AJ6
♣865
Dlr: East
Vul: N-S
♠T85
KQ
T832
♣KT42
♠9632
T6432
K4
♣Q3
♠AKQJ
8
Q975
♣AJ97
10
85
17
Double Dummy Makes
NS: 4♣ 4 3 4♠ 3NT
EW:  ♣3 ♦3 ♥3 ♠3 NT3
LoTT: 13 - 14 = -1
Par: +620 4♠-NS
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract
  600          3.50   0.50  3N S      A3-Sheketoff-Sheketoff vs A1-Fine-Greenberg
  600          3.50   0.50  3N N      A2-Masterson-Tischler vs A4-Porter-Bergin Wilson
  180          2.00   2.00  2N N +2   A5-Schwartz-Schwartz vs A5-Nothdurft-Dooley
        100    0.50   3.50  3N N -1   A1-Lieberman-McAlpin vs A2-Lampert-Murphy
        100    0.50   3.50  3N N -1   A4-Carr-O'Connor vs A3-Levin-Goldberg
19 ♠T7
9432
K4
♣QJT64
Dlr: South
Vul: E-W
♠KQ2
AQT
AQT2
♣A93
♠A963
KJ865
63
♣85
♠J854
7
J9875
♣K72
6
218
5
Double Dummy Makes
NS:  ♣5 ♦4 ♥1 ♠2 NT1
EW: 1♣ 2/3 5 4♠ 5NT
LoTT: 16 - 16 = 0
Par: -660 5NT-EW
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract
  100          4.00   0.00  4 W -1   A2-Masterson-Tischler vs A4-Porter-Bergin Wilson
        600    3.00   1.00  3N W      A5-Schwartz-Schwartz vs A5-Nothdurft-Dooley
        650    2.00   2.00  4 W +1   A1-Lieberman-McAlpin vs A2-Lampert-Murphy
        660    1.00   3.00  3N W +2   A3-Sheketoff-Sheketoff vs A1-Fine-Greenberg
        680    0.00   4.00  5 W +1   A4-Carr-O'Connor vs A3-Levin-Goldberg
20 ♠KT64
9
AT754
♣K82
Dlr: West
Vul: Both
♠Q9853
K83
J93
♣J6
♠J72
AQT754
K8
♣T4
♠A
J62
Q62
♣AQ9753
10
710
13
Double Dummy Makes
NS: 5♣ 5 1♠ 1NT  ♥5
EW: 1  ♣2 ♦2 ♠6 NT4
LoTT: 18 - 18 = 0
Par: +600 5-NS/5♣-NS
  N-S   E-W    N-S    E-W   Contract
  600          4.00   0.00  5♣ S      A1-Lieberman-McAlpin vs A2-Lampert-Murphy
  200          3.00   1.00  3 E -2   A3-Sheketoff-Sheketoff vs A1-Fine-Greenberg
  150          1.50   2.50  4♣ S +1   A2-Masterson-Tischler vs A4-Porter-Bergin Wilson
  150          1.50   2.50  4♣ S +1   A5-Schwartz-Schwartz vs A5-Nothdurft-Dooley
  130          0.00   4.00  4♣ S      A4-Carr-O'Connor vs A3-Levin-Goldberg